A controversial circuit court judge isn't waiting for lawmakers to determine his future. He's deciding it himself. Judge Kenneth Goode says he'll retire when his term ends this year. He's been on the bench since 1999. Recently, several lawmakers and others have been highly critical of Goode, for what they call his light treatment of several cases.
Last December, Judge Goode sentenced day care provider Talisha Smith to probation after she pled guilty to abusing a young child. And last month the judge heard a case involving a registered sex offender, who repeatedly violated his probation. An officer asked the judge to revoke that probation. Instead Goode allowed Zail Gavin to remain free, with conditions.
Two women, directly affected by the judge's decisions both feel vindication.
"It really helps to give us as citizens some faith back in our judicial system," said Michelle Gaddie.
Gaddie feels her efforts have paid off. 19-month old Kendra Gaddie's mother is relieved that Judge Kenneth Goode's days on the bench are numbered. Gaddie's daughter was 7-months-old when day care provider Talisha Smith severely injured her. Smith faced a possible 20-years in jail. Judge Goode gave her five-years probation.
"The citizens of SC don't want judges on the bench that are pro-defense or pro-victim. We want judges on the bench that are pro-justice," said Gaddie. "Plain and simple."
Last month lawmakers voted to put Goode through a "Judicial Merit Screening Review," to determine his capability to remain on the bench. A decision is no longer necessary.
Amy Hilley is satisfied the judge will soon put down his gavel. But what he'll draw in retirement bothers her.
"Knowing he makes about $130,000 a year and getting 70% in retirement is somewhat shocking to me," said Hilley.
Judge Goode gave Zail Gavin repeated breaks, despite probation violations. Hilley lives in Greenwood County, where Gavin was convicted of being a Peeping Tom.
"He did make a wrong right by retiring by stepping down," said Hilley. "I don't wish Judge Goode any ill-will."
Judge Goode did not respond to our request for an interview.
As for what's next, Michelle Gaddie says despite the judge's retirement she will continue her crusade to pass a bill establishing a minimum sentence for anyone who commits a violent crime against children.
And on March 25th, the Joint Assembly will meet to elect a successor to Judge Goode.
TV Station Profiles & Public Inspection Files forWACH